She is really hot,i just heard that she is hooking up with a tall basketball player on a tall dating place named: ---Tallmingle.c o m---,really?

she is ugly and her wide shoulders are out of proportion with the rest of her body

HOWDY THERE THUNDER THIGHS !

manly arms? CHECK
LIne backer neck? CHECK

big horse thunder thighs? CHECK

Dumped by ex boyfriend by a skinnier girl because your too fat? CHECK

built like a boy? CHECK

Actually she looks fat not muscular.

She's delishy.

she is trying too hard to look like britney(in her good days)

britney was musuclar and hot....hilary is muscular and manly

wow! everyone commenting above are so incredibly stupid!
ifshe is "FAT" well thats why she has a personal trainer retards!!!

and trying to look like britnet in her good days?
yeahhhh....i DOUBT hilary spends her time thinking of
ways to look like britney spears!

seriously! get lives retards!

don't hate hilary,
cause she's prettier and richer than you!
that's the only think you can insult her on,

her shoulders and weight.
ouch. that sooo hurts right?

losers!

she looks gorguzzz sexyy and is not fat!!

All the haters gets a life and look at ur self in the mirror

She does not look fat. She is the healthy weight for her size. She could tone up a bit but I think she looks great otherwise. AT least she isn't living off coffee and cigs like the Trollsens.

What a fat pig!! She is not a size zero anymore!!! She might be EATING!!!! the shame of it. She is worth nothing. No more big boobs with a skelatal body. why should she even go on living???? Now that she is eating she might actually have thoughts in her head that might benefit her and society and not just starve herself and obsess on food and plastic surgery. We can't have that!! please someone put her out of her misery. What is this world coming to???? LOL

Very cute girl.

you people are effed in the head if you think shes fat. eff all of you.

She is human you fucks. Not all girls are a size zero. Stop being so superficiall

She is human you fucks. Not all girls are a size zero. Stop being so superficial - she for sure isn't fat - look around.

Id still help her lose calories...alot of calories!

I love her! Ans she looks better than you hating bitches! And has more money!!

take that, take that

if that's muscular...
then i am too...
but my friends kept calling me fat girl...
but she's not???
her thigh is bigger than usual..
arms look flabby like mine...
oh well.. who's complaining any way.

I see post after post here and at JJ of her and Mikey dining out, they both need to tone up, he gets bloated like a woman.

Carbs are not your friend Hilly.

omg.
shes not fat
just because she looks normal and unlike the rest of these celebs
i think she looks good

It wouldnt matter if she weighed 100 pounds or 160 pounds, she'd still be pretty...that's why yall are hatin on her.

u ugly bitches just because shes hot and your not doesn't mean that u can say that

if you don't like hilary duff,
hate her and don't like her because she's fat,
then why would waste your time, and comment a story on her?
why even bother reading a story on her?

there's obviously a part of you
that likes her, and that's why you can't help but comment on her. even if it's something negative.

don't hate her because you're not as pretty as her!

it's okay!

just get a life.
and go work on yourself!

if u think shes fat ur a retard cus' shes normal for her size and u guys out their who like anorixic girls go stuff ur stupid face:))))))

sheeeeee soooooooo HOT damn !!!!

hillary annoying fans that keep defending her fat idol? CHECK

beetlejuice wouldn't touch that

I think people who hate her or her figure are just jealous pigs. You cant be her, you cant be like her, you hate her yet you dont even know her personally? This is how discrimination starts. For no apparent good reason at all other than selfishness.

Unless it totally unethical she has a right to look the way she wants.

Now dont forget about the 10lbs the camera adds

Wow,ever heard of spell check? Watch your language! Why would anyone write such mean things about anyone...

Hilary is s cool

All of you miley cyrus fans are sluts, just like her.

Hilary is s cool

All of you miley cyrus fans are sluts, just like her.

mind control is a great tool for satan in this copntest we all loose
the mind control destroyed the mind where chrsit is and the holy spirit the drug was more importatn keep on doing drugs it will be a great end sodom and gomorah

seriously - have any of you seen hilary the past few years, she clearly got too skinny. i think she looks great and is setting a much better example for younger girls. at least you can't see her bones like you can on carrie underwood. yuck!
Go Hillary!!! Be healthy and beautiful.

oh my goodness! some of you people are just so mean! i mean come on, no one's perfect. i think hilary duff is a down-to-earth celebrity, and i think she's awesome!!

She looks so hot and fit love this girl.

First of all, I have to say that Hilary looks great! She looks normal, not over dressed, overdone, etc. Second of all, when was being a little chunky so wrong? Because all the magazines say its better to be "tweaker" thin?! She obviously notices that shes not in tip top shape because she is working on it. Wow, some of you people on here are so superficial or else only care about hurting others to make yourself feel better. It's pathetic!

First of all, I have to say that Hilary looks great! She looks normal, not over dressed, overdone, etc. Second of all, when was being a little chunky so wrong? Because all the magazines say its better to be "tweaker" thin?! She obviously notices that shes not in tip top shape because she is working on it. Wow, some of you people on here are so superficial or else only care about hurting others to make yourself feel better. It's pathetic!

i think she looks fine. a few years ago like in cheaper by the dozen 2, she looked creepy and too thin..

She looks great. Beef up the thighs a little & she's a 10.

i dont see any of u saying this about queen latifa first of all shes not fat if u half to be that mean then u guys have nothing better to do with your time but pick on other people well give it up she looks great and there is nothing wrong with her i rather her look like that then nicole richey who wants to be that thin thats not healthy dip shits so grow up stop being rude or hurt full.

I don't think she looks fat....I actually thought she was way too skinny....there's nothing wrong with some curves!

first of all if you're all saying that in order to feel better then fine...but her singing skills is somethin. Try lookin some more on the inside. We should not judge other people. That's just insecurities

FATT!!!!

she is too muscular.
anyway, stop saying she's phat. She is not phat. The reason why she looks bigger is beacuse she is building muscle in she system. Muscle is way different than phat. I'm not a fan of her, but u guys who are insulting her that she's phat need a life. Phat people ROCK! You just don't like big people beacuse they are better than you. Not all female celebreties have to be skinny as hell. They look like sticks. We need more female celebrties w/ curves.

Gosh she has put on alot of weight though!!! I didnt like her when she was scary skinny, but she could loose a few pounds now...

Despite all the negative comments, I think she looks alright. Anyone who is calling her fat needs to get their eyes checked and are just jealous they aren't her. Its nice that she's staying in shape unlike some lazy people who are commenting on here!

First you people were talking about how skinny she was, now you say she is fat?!! I say get a life and worry about something more important than Hilarys thighs!

Great goddess you guys are a bunch of idiots, for everyone making a "fat" comment, please, tell us how much you weight? how tall are you? do you have more fat that you bmi says you should? get over it people, she's a human being, and so are you, leave her alone and let her live her life!

100% guaranteed that everyone that called her fat is a jealous ass girl. there are no guys here that would ever consider duff fat. shes effing gorgeous and you guys only wish you could look like that and walk around with a 2500$ tote bag, roll around in a $130k car, and shop at the most exlusive and expensive department store in the US, if not the world...

Thunder thighs? Some guys really LOVE women with big thighs. They are great for supporting babies. They come in handy for lovemaking too. Try it sometime. You might just enjoy it!

For a ceLeb, she is a fat one..
but for an ordinary and a regular girL, she's looking just fine.. :)

She just needs to tone her arms,otherwise the girl looks great. It must be only jealous, stupid girls who'd think she was fat and had thunder thighs. REAL men like girls with curves. Gives them something to really hold on too, not a piece of twig.

Hey you. The one whose friends call you fat girl. GET SOME NEW FRIENDS. You don't need idiots like that working on your self esteem.

Just because she is not stick thin like the rest of Hollywood does not mean she is fat you haters

shes a natural beauty.always was always will be.any normal hetero guy would love her.

making love to a skinny woman is like falling on a pile of coathangers.

she looks ok for a hollyhood grl

I think she looks super cute. All the negativity is just because you are a hater. You never hear anything bad about this girl. She carries herelf with style and grace.

I think she looks super cute. All the negativity is just because you are a hater. You never hear anything bad about this girl. She carries herself with style and grace.

I'm sure many of the nay-sayers commenting here are either overweight or narrowminded, and somehow feel that it's alright for them to be that way because they're not famous and aren't out there in the limelight. Every body is different, and no one wants to hear you call out on other peoples percieved imperfections. Attempt to better yourself by recognizing beauty in others, and by not pointing out what you think are "flaws". You're just spamming existence.

I`d like to see her naked

shes famous for a reason.. she looks good always :)

wow are you guys seriously saying that hilary duff is fat??
how STUPID
she is gorgeous just the way she is. she doesnt need to please you guys. so just shut up and get a life

:)

In my opinion i think she is very healthy and normal..i think her size is perfect..whoever that say bad things about her are so lame and wasting time because she has something special that you don't...i love you hilary, keep your head up and dont listen to the losers..=)

I think she looked scary thin before and her face didnt fit her new recaps on her teeth now that she is actually putting on weight she might be okay again. I always liked her when she was real not wanting to be skinny because someone said she was fat in a magazine. Its time for woman to stand up for themselves a size 0 is not the only thing beautiful out there.

I'd hit it. I'd rather have Mandy Moore though.

DO YOU GUYS UNDERSTAND THE WORD FAT? HILARY IS NOT FAT SHE IS LOOKING VERY NICE AND BEAUTIFUL. I THINK IS YOUR MUM WHO IS FATTTTT!!!!!!

I thought she was anorexic

you think she has thunder thighs? I dont think youve seen thunder thighs then cuz those are not it. They look like normal thighs and she looks nothing like britney spears not even close if anything hilary has defined her own look and style and not copied somebody elses.

Wow so if you think that she the one who has more money makes her better than us. Look at yourself, I bet she is much more wealthier than "who ever said that" too. Therefore, we're just in the same rank. How do you know that she is prettier and better than we are just by reading our outrageous comments. Respect what I have to say. Get a life. I don't even care if she looks like Britney Spears. Britney Spears might even have more talents than CELARY BUFF.

Wow so if you think that she the one who has more money makes her better than us. Look at yourself, I bet she is much more wealthier than "who ever said that" too. Therefore, we're just in the same rank. How do you know that she is prettier and better than we are just by reading our outrageous comments. Respect what I have to say. Get a life. I don't even care if she looks like Britney Spears. Britney Spears might even have more talents than CELARY BUFF.

I,ve met her, she's really pretty and tiny. if she's fat then so is Nicole Ritchie. you people need to sort out your insecurities big time!!!

she was cool but now i don't know