I think Court would bring a whole new vibe to the show. The show will either get more views due to the fact that people want to see how Court handels, OR it will lose views because people loved Paula. OR both, then it just cancels out. But if American Idol loses a few views I don't think it would do much harm. If I were FOX I would let Court be a guest judge for a week or two, if the ratings go up, keep her & ditch Paula, if they go down, ditch Court. Simple as that!

I think Court would bring a whole new vibe to the show. The show will either get more views due to the fact that people want to see how Court handels, OR it will lose views because people loved Paula. OR both, then it just cancels out. But if American Idol loses a few views I don't think it would do much harm. If I were FOX I would let Court be a guest judge for a week or two, if the ratings go up, keep her & ditch Paula, if they go down, ditch Court. Simple as that!

will paula be as f****ed up when court guests as she was when jewel guested on th 1st show. If somebody would compare the video of paula between the 1st an 2nd show it would be all that needs 2 b said

uuuuhhh, I know I had my coffee this morning, so I'm not asleep....or hallucinating....why would they replace one train wreck with another....one who claims to be sober but looks TORE UP in every photo and could barely put a sentence together at one of the awards shows.....????

They are NOT going to replace Paula...PERIOD!!

Every other week there are rumors that she is going to be replaced and I just don't see that happening. That would throw off the chemistry of the whole show to bring someone else in.

I don't see that happening. Why would Fox ruin a good thing? Controversy is the best form of free advertising.

They are NOT going to replace Paula...PERIOD!!

Every other week there are rumors that she is going to be replaced and I just don't see that happening. That would throw off the chemistry of the whole show to bring someone else in.

I don't see that happening. Why would Fox ruin a good thing? Controversy is the best form of free advertising.

LOOK AT THE TWEAKER next to Courtney. Courtney is the coke tweaker whore.....

LOOK AT THE TWEAKER next to Courtney. Courtney is the coke tweaker whore.....

ewwwww.
keep Courtney away from my tv show please.

Paula is SOOOOOO hot. I loved her curvy slutty body with that big old Italian ass. I bet she would look great in a mini skirt with a big ol strapon under it. I wonder if she takes it up the bum? You just know Courtney does but she is gnarly.

I love Watching Paula get drunk and dance like crazy during the performances. So I say keep Paula just for my entertainment. Courtney would be fun too though. Maybe they should replace Simon with Courtney!

Simon's moobs are way too big for TV.

a. courtney is a shite singer.
b. kurt wrote most of the music of courtney's 'successful' cd.
c. courtney is a murderer.
d. courtney is a bigger lush than paula ever will be & if they replace paula w/ courtney it will be because they feel america would tune in to watch the train wreck that is courtney love.
e. i will boycott idol if they do this.

They are NOT going to replace Paula...PERIOD!!

Every other week there are rumors that she is going to be replaced and I just don't see that happening. That would throw off the chemistry of the whole show to bring someone else in.

I don't see that happening. Why would Fox ruin a good thing? Controversy is the best form of free advertising.

They are NOT going to replace Paula...PERIOD!!

Every other week there are rumors that she is going to be replaced and I just don't see that happening. That would throw off the chemistry of the whole show to bring someone else in.

I don't see that happening. Why would Fox ruin a good thing? Controversy is the best form of free advertising.

ewwwww.
keep Courtney away from my tv show please.

Paula ,Randy and Simon are hilarious together!

Simon already said Paula isn't going anywhere. US mag is wrong as usual

Paula is getting boring. Bring on Courtney and get more craziness and even more bitching onto the show! That's what the viewers want to see!

Team Courtney for the win. I don't watch American Idol now, but I'd start if Courtney got hired.

i like the idea of courtney being on american idol, it will give me a reason to even watch the show..she is just good tv.

Courtney being on AI?!? Are you freaking serious. How can anyone even consider replacing Paula. I mean she is what gave this show its running start and without the famous trio, the show would be nothing. Replace one judge, and the rest go to. Trust me. The minute Paula goes, Simon will not be far behind and that will tear apart this show for good.