How Skinny Is Too Skinny?

Oh this is sure to muster up some lovely comments.

Not fair, X17. Would you make a post about girls that are too fat? Such a double-standard. These girls can't help being slender. That doesn't make them un-sexy. Sexy comes in all shapes and sizes.

does it matter if they are 'skinny'? based on some of their heights, their weight is not a bad thing. nicole richie is just over 5 foot tall.

Too skinny? Nah! Not for the overweight drunks that are online looking at their pictures right now.

Depends on how tall they are.

These women look fantastic. Compare them to Shitney, with her tree-trunk legs, line backer neck and flabby arms...they're all much more attractive.

people nowadays dont care about fatness thats why people were more beautiful in the past

lets see a pic of your fat ass andy

Depends on height and body type,and main thing is,as long as they are healthy,it's all good!

Annalynne McCord is PERFECT. The others can stand to gain a few. Really some of these girls are naturally skinny while others have to work hard to stay that way. Healthy is what matters.

OMG NICOLE IS JUST PERFECT! hot and beautiful! just shanae is a little skinny than normal, but is she is beatiful too!

victoria beckham - "posh" is no.1 - skinnest definately. others - just nice.

If I wanted to f a bag of bones, I would go to the cemetery. These women are gross with their pointy bodies and sharp bones sticking out. I'm not perfect, but I'm 5'11" and 180. Give me a woman like Salma Hayek or Jennifer Lopez any day. At least they are soft and have curves. How anyone thinks they are just "thin" is beyond me. They look ill.

Maybe X17 should skip analyzing weight of celebrities and revisit English 101 and brush up on their fact-checking. "IS any of these sexy females too sexy"? Try ARE any of these . . . and it's ANNA LYNNE not ANNYALYNNE. Sheesh!

Fat is NEVER beautiful!!!

Let 'em all wither away except Jen Con. The rest of them are famous for....hmm...I don't know...do you?

Yeah...Jennifer and Taylor look like skeletons. Barf.

PEOPLE SHOULDNT JUDGE THEM FOR BEING SKINNY!!!

I AM SUPER SKINNY LIKE THEM AND NOT BECAUSE I DONT EAT WELL BUT BECAUSE IM JUST LIKE THAT...I EAT HAMBURGUERS, BUTTERY POP CORN, FRIES, AND ALL KIND OF JUNKS AND I DONT GAIN WEIGHT.....I ALSO GO TO THE GYM COUPLE OF DAYS A WEEK...I'D SAY 3 DAYS A WEEK FOR HOUR AND A HALF...OR SOMETIMES I EVEN GO JUST TWICE A WEEK....
-
IM SICK AND TIRED OF PEOPLE JUDGING ME BECAUSE IM TOO SKINNY WITHOUT EVEN KNOWING ME AT ALL!!!!!
-
BY THE WAY I HATE SALADS! BUT I KNOW I HAVE TO EAT THEM ONCE IN A WHILE BECAUSE IS HEALTHY....

im anorexic and this is not fair!!! im 5ft11 and 99 pounds so yer and showing this or saying that is not well its wrong! why dont ya switch huh? do one on who's the fattest! no you wont cos thats cruel right??

Jennifer looks sick the last time I saw her on Letterman.
Shenae looks out of proportion--with this tiny body and a big head.
Nicole is fine...less than what she is now would be too skinny.
Victoria just looks old-skinny; the kind that looks haggard looking.
AnnyL looks healthy.
Taylor looks like a druggie.

Too skinny is when the upper legs aren't much bigger than below the knee and when the end of the colar bones are visible in the shoulders.
Everyone pictured is too thin.
And anorexia dear Kitt @11:08 is a serious psychiatric problem that goes much further than not eating enough or vomiting or using pills. If you really are anorexic go get help before you're caught in all the maniac side effects of this eating disturbance that ruins your life, AND the life of your family and friends.

My Peenis weighs more than any of those little b*tches!

you are sickos . bacause you tell us how beautiful britney looks like althrough she is still ugly and psycho and fat . you guys told girls for centuries how skinny they have to be and showed them every piece of fat from older actors and now you complain when somebody looks fine .
Its easy to hide behind your cams and judge other humans . they are humans and not dolls . to stay in shape is not easy so leave them alone

X17 is so stupid. We all know that if any of these women gained 10 pounds X17 would call them fat.

Your a walrus aren't you Amy?

maybe their boyfriends like them like that

Men like meat....no bones !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

These women do not look unhealthy. Maybe they do to Americans, but the average American is not considered to be the picture of health any way.
This body type is not a rare sight to see, I see women with this body type all the type. They arent anorexic. Some of you need to get over yourselves.

*time

Needless to say, she has very cute looking!! lots pretty chicks like her should be very famous on the Interracial dating site: ___Multiraciallove.com___. Maybe she can join to attend the sexy session to attract tall guys!! at least, that's what my bros and i happen to know!!

and Angelina Jolie?

never too rich or too thin

No new news here. Jump over to Perez Hilton for the latest.

people and their obsession with weight. christ!

Rosie, if you have a peen I'm concerned.

Nicole & Victoria look AWESOME. The others look hideous (and that wannabe chic with her ridiculous poses & outfits is a disaster) - especially Jennifer Connolly who carries most of her weight in her eyebrows. She's scary.

Off to Perez we go. No news here. You're right 8:52.

Victoria is way too skinny. Just a stick with two big ballons of silicon.

Health should come first, but THIS IS Ho(e)llywood.

The camera puts on 10 lbs so its natural for X17 to know who is TOO thin.

I think NR is probably naturally thin. She was heavy when she was doing drugs.
SG has bobble-head syndrome. Your body can only take so much alcohol and cigarettes. Eventually, it will come to light if these women are naturally thin, or just killing themselves.
ALM seems to be naturally thin.
Posh was heavier in the 90's. She is getting that old saggy look.
Taylor looks sick.
Jen C. Looks sick (just look at her from one year ago)

Here are some chicks that should be on the list.

1. Paris Hilton (her face looks like she's in her 40's)
2. Jada Pinkett Smith (I saw her in person and she looks like a boy)
3. SaMANtha Ronson (she probably survives on cigarettes and booze)

Again, health is the most important. Being overweight isn't cool, but starving yourself can have long term affects. Check out real thin actresses...they are starting to look very old.

A lot of people on that list are not going out of their way to starve themselves, they are just naturally thin. People with smaller bone structures are not sick or partying too hard just because you say so.

If the camera really does add weight, then maybe they should gain a bit. I think Nicole looks good. Posh is disgusting-too skinny and too orange. Shenae I have always thought to be unattractive, but more about her face than her body.

kitt 11:08 if you are seriously anorexic you should really get help and the fact that you are saying that in such a calm way as if it was logic just proves that you really need help. please go get it before you kill yourself.
I do think some people in the list are skinny but some of them are probably skinny naturally, but its no good to go to extremes and be super skinny or super fat, the best is to find a balance and eat healthy

Nicole could do with a few kilos.
Shenae is naturally skinny but yeah, a few pounds wouldn't hurt.
Anna is fit.
Victoria is way too thin. Compare her thighs against Anna's.
Jennifer is too thin also.

Nicole could do with a few kilos.
Shenae is naturally skinny but yeah, a few pounds wouldn't hurt.
Anna is fit.
Victoria is way too thin. Compare her thighs against Anna's.
Jennifer is too thin also.

Yea, like another post on here, you can never be too skinny.

Those girls look perfect! We need more people to look like them in the world.

they all look fine to me, and how dare you post anything bad about Jennifer, she looks greay, very pretty.

Every single one of those girls needs to eat a donut...or a dozen!

Every single one of those girls needs to eat a donut...or a dozen! ...as well as many others not posted.

I agree with Scott @ 10:47am..only NICOLE and VICTORIA look awesome! It's because they are NATURALLY small and thin! Yes..Victoria was SLIGHTLY meaty when she first emerged with the Spice Girls..but she's NOT so big that her body now makes so much difference than how she was before! If anything, she's only about 5 kilos less than she was in 1997. She is healthier than she looks in 2006, more meatier. And Nicole looks slightly better than her pre-relationship with Joel.

Oh, simmer down people. If you eat small portions of healthful foods, you're bound to stay thin. Like me :) However most of these girls are probably coke whores :)

they are not skinny. they are just fine. if you want to see skinny actress, look for Kim Chui, that is what you call skinny.

i think they all look great an im american which most americans are praising the idea of being fat or at least 15 to 25 pounds heavier than any person should be. im 5'2 and im small boned so i know what it is to be petite and i think they all look great. Besides i think when youre thin your more aware of yourself and your sexual attractiveness and thats the triple threat of being thin or skinny in the first place and thats very important . This generation believes the exact opposite of all ive said and they look forward to being overweight as if there some virtue in that and they find joy in making fun of anyone who is skinny.