SAG-y Starlets: Who Looked Best and Who Looked a Hot Mess?

I like America, Christina, and Amanda.

I just think the Awards treat these women as dogs!

Um, America doesn't look like she's shrinking to me, but even if she was, so what? She's a talented and beautiful girl, and I don't think she's overweight, but it wouldn't kill her if she lost a few, either. Not that she NEEDS to, but if she did it wouldn't be the end of the world.

Anyway, I'd say America looks the best overall. I love her dress, makeup, hair, everything. Of the others, I'd say Ellen and Amanda have the best makeup, Christina has the best dress, and Ashley looks like shit. The Sandra Oh picture wouldn't load, but I'm sure whatever she was wearing was fugtacular. Someone needs to tell her that she is not and will never be Chloe Sevigny.

Christina looks totally gorgeous, I don't think a necklace is missing, the dress is already to sparkly, maybe some longer and bigger earings. But she looks amazing. America, altough she is not beautifull, looks very good, the dress is beautifull.

Ellen looks AMAZING!

I like them all, including the hair. We should all be so lucky to be able to go to an event like this. Now THIS kind of story is the reason I started reading sites like this. I want to see the glamour and the gowns, not bloody pads. Finally x17 does something right for a change

I luv Amanda's gown. The fabric is extraordinary! Her makeup is beautiful as well but the hair is uh.....yea.....not cute!

uhhh i don't see one place where america is shrinking and her dress is FUGLY!

out of these pics, amanda looks the best, even the hair. for this event, everything about her is very age appropriate. the best i've ever seen her.

It seems to me that this is the year of the Elaborate (and beautiful) Hairdo. So, no need for a necklace to detract from the hair.

Ellen is by far the best dressed

best hair and makeup as well

amanda bynes looked beautiful - hair needed just a little more volume, but her dress was gorgeous (sorry x17, not all the young girls need to dress like hoochey mamas to show off their figure and so you can take pics of their crotch). christina looked great...i don't think she needed a necklace since the dress was sparkly enough - though her dress kind of looked like it was an old beyonce dress. america looked gorgeous too, though not a huge fan of the hairstyle, but it worked with the style of the dress.

She is definitely losing weight. Either that or the gown she is wearing is extrememly flattering! In any case,she looks great

Amanda does have a great figure and she could easily wear something more fitted, but still, the dress is gorgeous! She could have done a tad better on the hair, but overall my opinion is that she looks stunning. America is right up there for me too.

Marion Cotillard is just beautiful and was my favorite. What in the heck was Debra Messing wearing? It was unflattering for her shape and made her chest look manly.

Marion Cotillard is just beautiful and was my favorite. What in the heck was Debra Messing wearing? It was unflattering for her shape and made her chest look manly.

Marion Cotillard is just beautiful and was my favorite. What in the heck was Debra Messing wearing? It was unflattering for her shape and made her chest look manly.

The dress' of America and Amanda are extremely pretty, Ellen is a shiny spaceman! Ashley's head is HUGE, chick should've kept the nose atleast she was recognizable.

uhh, what does this have to do with christina aguilera? that is christina appelgate!!! idiots

this article was placed under x17online.com/celebrities/christina_aguilera as well. wow pay attention before you post!!!

You guys are so fucking stupid...you don't know makeup hair or fashion. STFU X17!

I find it amusing that you're critiquing anyone's look when you consistantly find your Queen B looking beautiful and stunning!! Kind of damages your credibility as fashion critics!

Mmm, is America single now? I saw her profile on millionaire dating site W e a l t h yR o m a n c e.com last week. Just curious.

I think this is the first picture of Ashley T. after the nose job where she is fully made up. She looks wonderful. The hair looks great too. Christina just keeps getting better with age.

Amanda is chunky as hell and not very pretty. Ashlee tisdale or however it's spelled really screwed up her face with that craptastic nose job.

amanda

Hollywood worships ugly.

Christina Applegate is absolutely HOT..
She's a great actress and I'm glad she's finally in a show that shows off her talent.

Ashley Tisdale looks like an afghan hound.

ashley looks great!, i love her!