AItop12guys.jpgPhoto credit: Patrick Ecclestein/FOX

And it seems there was a clear favorite: the sexy Texan Casey James!

The Top 12 men of American Idol hit the stage Wednesday night to perform for Simon, Kara, Randy and Ellen - Casey sang Bryan Adams' "Heaven," but the judges' attention was all on Kara, who had previously admitted to crushing on the guy.

Even Ellen apologized afterward for disrupting his performance! Thankfully, everyone loved Casey. Simon said: "All the kidding aside, what I really liked about you today was you absolutely chose the right song, it came over as very honest, very sincere, you came over as very likable."

The other interesting moment came after Alex Lambert's version of "Wonderful World," and Simon called it "the most uncomfortable performance of the night." Ouch!

Who's gonna make it through? And who's your fave? I liked Lee the best!