nicolejoelcheatingrum.jpg We certainly hope not, but that's the cover story on Star mag this week, and everyone seems to have their theories about it.

X17online was given information about a year ago that Joel had been unfaithful in his relationship with Nicole, but we were unable to confirm the claims so we never reported the story. This would have been a separate incident, way before Star Magazine’s report of an incident in May, so we have to ask, is someone out to sabotage their relationship with lies?

The folks at E! have a source who completely slams Star's report that Joel cheated on his babymama, and guess what? Their source just so happens to be the person that Star is claiming leaked the info in the first place! The mag claims Joel Madden was cozying up to a mystery blonde at a West Palm Beach club last May, but DJ J.R. Hutter of Feelgoods Rock Bar and Grill says, "Star completely made up those quotes."

The cover story claimed that when Joel and his twin brother Benji were done at the club they invited two female workers on their tour bus, but Hutter shoots down that report and said, "Joel was actually talking about his wife and kids the whole time. He even mentioned he was getting married. He was just trying to make sure everyone was having a good time and ordering the drinks. He wasn't even drinking himself. He was taking pictures with fans. There was nothing crazy or out of the ordinary."

As for rocking their tour bus, Hutter added, "A couple of the cocktail waitresses saw the show the next night and hung out with them backstage, but after they didn't go on their tour bus. They even went to a barbecue before and later hung out on Drake's bus. After the set, the girls drove back to Palm Beach and haven't talked to either brother since."

So there you have it! But who's trying to stir up trouble? Is it a jealous jilted ex of Joel's, or is someone sick of the Brangelina cheating rumors? I guess it's time another couple was added to the list!