What did you guys think of my performance?! . #dontstopbelieving

A post shared by Alex Rodriguez (@arod) on


They are just so cute!

J.Lo serenaded A-Rod with her version of Journey's "Don't Stop Believin'" on a boat yesterday night, and the baseball great was so impressed with her performance, he decided to upload a clip to Instagram so that everyone could see.

Fans immediately began to comment on how happy and in love they seemed, and started urging the MLB legend to pop the question.

While the athlete has yet to officially propose, he did explain why they're so well suited for each other during a recent appearance on Today.

"To be honest if this happened when we were in our twenties... it would have never happened. It was just too much craziness, I wasn't mature enough. You know boys.... we gotta get our dumbness out of the way. We're both in our 40s, we're both from New York, we both come from Latino backgrounds, we both have two kids. I think we've both been through a lot and can really appreciate each other... both the good and the challenges," he revealed.

He'd be an idiot not to put a ring on it!