Katie Holmes katienickypolka11.jpg

Both Nicky Hilton and Katie Holmes have recently been spotted (pun intended) wearing the same Comme des Garcon for H&M black and white polka dot cardigan, but with very different outfits. Nicky dressed up the $69.90 sweater with a short skirt and Chanel accessories, while Katie rocked the cardigan with jeans and a matching polka dot scarf for a more casual look.

So who's more on the dot, Nicky or Katie?